Summary of Reviews
We have read all expert and user reviews on the Marin Bobcat Trail. In summary, this is what cyclists think.
10 reasons to buy
- Owners and experts say the Bobcat is good value, especially with the stock Shimano gears and Sunrace fork.
- The frame is lightweight, has bosses for two water bottle cages and rear stays that accommodate tires at least 2.35” wide. It’s also durable, lasting one owner seven years before selling it on.
- The slack geometry was described as confidence-inspiring and lauded for its modern angles.
- The economical Tektro hydraulic disc brakes on the Bobcat 3 - surprised experts with their effectiveness, one comparing them to the Shimano discs on the higher-end Bobcat 4.
- The wheels on 29” models served as a good balance between light weight and strength. They also offered improved rollover and traction.
- The high-end ‘LTD XT’ model wowed with high quality Shimano XT kit, while other models were equipped with low-cost Acera and Altus derailleurs that still performed well in expert tests.
- The wider bars on the Bobcat 4 proved satisfactory for throwing the bike around on aggressive trails.
- On basic models, the Shimano componentry (including hubs and rear-mech) were considered reliable.
- Tough Tom 2.25” tires proved durable and capable of tackling varied terrain.
- The Marin double-wall rims were praised as ‘rock solid’ and the 25mm width provided options for fat tires.
6 reasons not to buy
- The shock on lower-end models has no lockout and an upgrade from 100 to 120mm was suggested. It was described as more suited to cross-country and allrounders.
- It was suggested that entry-level models needed a shorter stem and a handlebar wider than 720mm.
- The bottle-mount on the seat-tube prevents lowering of the seat-post, frustrating some trail-riders.
- The 3x8 triple-chainring was considered heavy, antiquated and more suited to cross-country and commuting. On wilder trails, the chain slipped off and slapped stays.
- The Bobcat is a light frame draped with heavy (but durable) components. The bike might be a bit heavy for beginner cyclists with limited strength.
- One expert had a consistent issue with the rear tire rubbing on the front derailleur.
Expert Reviews70/100 based on 6 expert reviews
Test: Marin Bobcat Trail 4 (29er)
The Marin Bobcat proves that even at a low price, you can design a bike with mature geometry. Despite the many budget components that will eventually need to be modified, Bobcat offers a lot of riding fun, predictability and stability…