Summary of Reviews

We have read all expert and user reviews on the Cannondale Scalpel. In summary, this is what cyclists think.

11 reasons to buy

Cannondale offers this bike in four builds: Scalpel 1 and 2 with SRAM AXS, and 3 and 4 with Shimano mechanical.
Experts relish the Scalpel's stiff, responsive frame.
Reviewers say the suspension tune is so efficient that it doesn’t need a lockout.
Experts call the Scalpel a “rocket” on climbs.
A tester is pleased by how active the FlexPivot suspension platform remains under braking forces.
Reviewers are impressed by the Scalpel's descending capabilities for a short-travel bike.
Testers say the suspension effectively absorbs trail chatter.
Reviewers praise the abundant traction on technical climbs.
Experts say catching air is easy.
The Scalpel has mounts for two bottle cages, SRAM UDH, and a threaded bottom bracket.
Cannondale provides a lifetime frame warranty for the original registered owner.

7 reasons not to buy

Testers find the Maxxis Aspen WT rear tire easily loses traction.
Cable routing through the headset complicates maintenance and service.
The Scalpel doesn't have remote suspension lockout or internal storage.
Testers would prefer an infinite travel dropper versus the two-position FOX Transfer SL on the Scalpel 1 and 2.
One tester reports a creaking rear suspension linkage.
Some testers find the SRAM Level Bronze and Silver brakes (Scalpel 2 and 1) weak and lacking modulation.
Two testers think the 34t chainring is too large.

Bottom line

The Cannondale Scalpel is a race-ready XC mountain bike with 120mm of travel front and rear. The top two builds have SRAM wireless groupsets; the other two have Shimano mechanical. Experts are impressed with the bike's incredibly efficient pedaling platform. The stiff frame, well-balanced geometry, and excellent suspension tune all contribute to stellar performance, both on climbs and descents. Limited cockpit adjustability and headset-routed cables are the biggest frustrations for testers. The Scalpel isn't cheap, but it's in line with competitors, and testers consider it worth the price.

Where to buy

$3,349.00 eBay See it $3,199.00 $150 Discount Code $3,349.00 Cannondale See it $3,349.00 Contender Bicycles See it $3,798.95 Mike's Bikes See it $3,799.97 Gravity Coalition See it $4,000.00 Sun & Ski See it $7,998.94 Jenson USA See it

View all prices Show fewer prices

See at eBay

We earn affiliate commission. Learn more
Bike Size Charts

BikeRide finds and shows you the best prices of the bikes you want to buy. Prices constantly change and it’s impossible to compare them all yourself.

We search for prices on over 120 bike retailers to guarantee that we find the lowest prices – to save you time and money.

It’s a promise we stand behind: If you find a lower price on a bike elsewhere, we will sell it to you for 10% less. For example, if you find a bike for $480 that we have listed at $500, we will offer you to buy it for $432 through BikeRide. The bike must be the same color and size, sold in the US and not include the use of a coupon.

If you find a lower price, email us at [email protected] with documentation of the price. We’re committed to making sure that the cost of a bike does not keep you from cycling!