The frame was commended for its lustrous finish, with one user commenting that it showed no noticeable deterioration after more than three thousand miles of use.

Some riders initially intended to upgrade the saddle, before finding that the provided Selle Italia was more than adequate.

The componentry is high quality and bears recognized brands, such as Campagnolo and Vittoria.

The carbon frame contributes to a very light package, at under seventeen pounds.

Expert reviews highlighted the responsive action of the bike’s rear-triangle, which contributed toward a lively ride.

For owners, more options were opened up by the Zonda wheels’ allowance for wider 28c tires.

Handling was generally described as agile.

Two experts gave the Superstar high marks for good value, considering its quality.

Reports from long-term users and experts agree that this bike is comfortable on long-distance rides.

2 reasons not to buy

One expert mentioned that the head-tube sat a little high, but that this could be adjusted using the spacers provided.

One consumer described the carbon inside the frame tubes as being low-quality, though how they came to this conclusion is a mystery.

Bottom line

This seems to be a bike that impresses everyone who rides it. It isn't expensive in the grand scheme of road bike prices, but it could be expensive to a beginner cyclist. For the high-end componentry included as standard, experts found it to be good value. Reports are positive from riders who put high miles on the Superstar. If you can afford a high quality road bike that’s suitable for endurance rides, but aren’t interested in some kind of $7000 featherweight machine, the Superstar may suit you.

Expert Reviews

84/100 based on 4 rated expert reviews

Apply to become an expert

Cyclist

Level 5 expert

Cinelli Superstar Review

Level 5 expert

The Cinelli really is a dark horse, possessed with a love of climbing, an eagerness on flat and rolling roads, and a direct response to input that shames some high-end racing bikes.

Visit full review

Bikes Etc

Level 1 expert

Cinelli Superstar

Level 1 expert

Lightweight, rapid, stylish and a steal for the money.

Visit full review

ROADBIKE

Level 4 expert

Review: Cinelli Superstar Disc (model year 2017)

Level 4 expert

The new Cinelli Superstar Disc really has what it takes to become a superstar. It combines safe handling and high seating comfort with pronounced speed-greed.

Visit full review

Fiets

Level 4 expert